Ivan Toney vs Ollie Watkins
Ivan Toney vs Ollie Watkins: head-to-head — careers, honours, key numbers and why the rivalry matters.
Why compare Ivan Toney and Ollie Watkins?
As contemporaries in the Premier League, Toney and Watkins have been compared for their goal-scoring abilities and contributions to their respective teams.
Ivan Toney
Key numbers
- Total club appearancesover 300
- Total club goalsover 100
- International caps7
- International goals1
Top honours
- League One Top Scorer2019-20 season
- Player of the Season2019-20 season at Peterborough United
- Football League Trophy2015-16 with Barnsley
- League One Play-offs Winner2016 with Barnsley
- Premier League Promotion2021 with Brentford
VS
Ollie Watkins
Visit Ollie Watkins hubKey numbers
- Total club appearancesover 400
- Total goals scoredover 150
- International caps for England20
- International goals for England6
Top honours
- EFL Young Player of the Year2017
- Championship Player of the Year2020
- Premier League Playmaker of the Season2023-24
- Aston Villa's all-time top Premier League scorerSurpassed 74 goals in May 2025
- Joint top-scorer2019-20 Championship season